Page van der Linden

Desert Rock Coal Plant Update: Permit To Pollute

four-corners-coal-plants.jpg

Greetings from the Land Of Enchantment! It's been a pretty hot summer here in New Mexico. The federal government has just declared most of our counties drought disaster areas. Yes, we're definitely feeling the effects of global warming here in the American Southwest.

So, it's pretty ironic that the feds have decided to issue an air permit for a third greenhouse gas-belching coal fired power plant up in the Four Corners region of the state.

That's the Desert Rock Power Plant, and it's the last thing we need.

The New Mexico governor, as well as the New Mexico attorney general, agree.

A number of environmental groups* have been working hard to stop the Desert Rock project. Together, they released the following statement on July 31, 2008:

Despite objections from other federal agencies, the states of Colorado and New Mexico, local governments, Navajo tribal members and citizen groups, the EPA today issued an air quality permit for construction of the Desert Rock Energy Facility, an additional massive coal-fired power plant on Navajo land in northwest New Mexico.

“EPA’s irresponsible, inappropriate decision has failed Navajo communities and needlessly sacrificed our air, land and water,” said Dailan Long of Diné CARE. “It is a devastating blow to tribal members who continually suffer from the large coal complex encroaching upon our land.”

[...]

“This is a political decision, not one based on science or EPA’s own mandate,” said Mike Eisenfeld of San Juan Citizens Alliance. “EPA ramrodded this permit out the door in response to a lawsuit filed by the coal plant owner, whose lawyer, Jeff Holmstead, was a high-level EPA official in the Bush administration. It looks like he’s still giving orders to EPA’s staff.”

The permit’s numerous deficiencies — including the failure to assess and set required emissions limits for carbon dioxide, mercury, and ozone-forming pollutants — were made clear to the EPA in more than 1,000 comments submitted by other federal agencies, state and local governments, tribal members and organizations, and other citizen groups.

 

Governor Bill Richardson (D-NM) also responded immediately. He had this to say:

Governor Bill Richardson and Attorney General Gary King today announced their intention to immediately file an appeal of the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency’s ill-advised decision on issuing an air quality permit for the Desert Rock Energy Facility planned for the Navajo Nation.

By issuing the permit, a lawsuit filed by Sithe Global of Houston, Texas against EPA will most likely be dismissed. That lawsuit sought to force EPA to make a decision on the permit. EPA and Sithe Global apparently attempted to cut a deal to evade judicial review of new power plant.

“EPA is bending to the will of corporate, financial and misguided political interests that will pollute New Mexico’s skies,” Governor Richardson said. “EPA’s decision ignores its obligations to protect the health of residents and the environment in New Mexico and the region. We will not allow this ill-advised decision to stand.”

 

Gary King says that, legally, Desert Rock is "far from a done deal", since the EPA violated the Clean Air Act when it issued the permit.

Finally, NM Environment Department Secretary Ron Curry sums it up with:

“EPA is shirking its responsibility to require an analysis of several pollutants, including mercury, ozone and carbon dioxide – a greenhouse gas,” said New Mexico Environment Department Secretary Ron Curry. “This plant will increase the region’s annual greenhouse gas emissions by more than one third and wipe out our efforts to reduce these emissions across the state. The Four Corners area is already burdened with the high levels of mercury contamination and smog and this facility will only worsen those problems.”

 

In other words, the "Environmental Protection Agency" isn't exactly living up to its name.

Delaying the plant and examing the legality of the air permit is a step in the right direction.

However, I would like to call on Governor Richardson to do what he's done in the past: fight against corporate energy interests, and make a firmer stand on preserving the environment.

You've fought oil and gas development in the south of the state on Otero Mesa, Governor Richardson. You helped us win that battle (for now).

Now, help us win the battle in the Four Corners. 

*Many thanks to: The San Juan Citizens Alliance, Clean Air Task Force, Diné Citizens Against Ruining Our Environment, Sierra Club, Earthjustice, Environment Colorado, Environmental Defense Fund, Grand Canyon Trust, Natural Resources Defense Council, Western Resource Advocates, and Wild Earth Guardians for their hard work.

 


Alavert

Greeting. I have never been especially impressed by the heroics of people who are convinced they are about to change the world. I am more awed by those who struggle to make one small difference after another. Help me! Help to find sites on the: Alavert. I found only this - Alavert laptop computers. Doctors must closely monitor their patients use of synthroid. Htm side tasty of massive cream medication open mouth synthroid effects spicy lt; a lt; a href. Thank you very much :-(. Hanzila from Iran.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.